We’ve all heard it…scratch that. Most of us have probably said it at one time or another!
(In our pre-homeschooling mom days, of course!)
“Why read the book? I’ll just watch the movie.”
*Affiliate links may be present on this page. Please see the disclosure for details.
This might be the ultimate “I really don’t want to read that much” excuse…but it’s also a fantastic way to teach elements of literature. As a bonus, it also helps your teen become interested in great literature and writing projects!
Teaching Movies as Literature
If you think about it, great movies are great for a reason. They show mastery of storytelling, plot structure, theme, motivation, suspense, motif, and more, but in a visual format.
Movies are actually an excellent way to introduce a reluctant reader or writer to the skills of literature analysis.
And for the student who loves to read and write, it’s a fun way to dig into the skills of cinematic storytelling! You can make an incredible comparison study from a movies as literature unit: how do the elements differ on the page and on the screen?
This was actually something my son took on for himself a few years back, and he learned a lot from it. It’s a practice he still carries today!
A Christmas Carol
Charles Dickens’ classic short story, A Christmas Carol, is an excellent work to start out with for a movies as literature study.
For younger kids, the movie itself is a great one to dig into. There’s a lot there, but Dickens is an excellent storyteller, and even kids in the elementary grades can glean a lot from it. (I remember it being one of my favorites from around 2nd or 3rd grade!)
For kids in junior high and high school, you can go deeper into the study, even adding in a comparison project with the book. And there are fantastic activity ideas for every age!
Because Dickens can be a bit hard to understand at first, I recommend reading the book and watching the movie. The book is amazing in its own right, but the movie makes it come alive. I prefer the movie version starring George C. Scott. This version is engaging, easy to find, and a really good version.
Students will start out by watching the movie and recording their initial thoughts. Later in the study they will watch it again, digging deeper into the questions.
Comparing the Movie with the Book
If you would like to add the book, it does a lot to extend out the study!
There are a few different ways to do this.
We really enjoyed doing A Christmas Carol (and other works by Dickens) as a read aloud. You can do some really fun voices with it, and it allows for a lot of good discussion. It’s totally fine to do part or all of the guide questions through discussion!
Dickens can be pretty wordy though, so if you’re not up for reading it all yourself, you can also listen to it as a family on Audible. This also allows your kids to listen to it more than once!
And if your child prefers to read the book on their own, go for it! The literature guide will bring your child through the vocabulary, comprehension, literary analysis, and more.
There are so many fun activities you can do to round out this unit, or to bring younger kids into it. It makes a really fun December unit – literature, history, and Christmas in Victorian Britain!
My Pinterest Board for A Christmas Carol has lots of fun activities to choose from!
Comparing and contrasting different movie interpretations is fun and offers some great discussion! (Be sure to read reviews to determine which will be right for your family.) Here are some to choose from:
- Disney’s A Christmas Carol, starring Jim Carrey
- The 1951 version, starring Alastair Sim
- A Christmas Carol with Fredric March and Basil Rathbone
If you’re looking for an illustrated version, this one is gorgeous. And if you give books to your kids for Christmas, it would be a good one to consider!
If you’ve got an older child that loves to color, you can get the coloring book to go along with the study! (It would also be fun for you!)
A Christmas Carol: A Coloring ClassicA Christmas Carol: Coloring Book For KidsCrayola Colored Pencils, Pre-sharpened, Great for Adult Coloring, 50 CountPrismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, Soft Core, 72 Pack
The Bronze Bow Literature Unit (+ a free printable!)